Montieth Avenue – Hawthorne, NY
Montieth Avenue in Hawthorne, New York, is one of those quiet, tree-lined streets that quietly captures your heart. Tucked into the scenic town of Mount Pleasant in Westchester County, Montieth Avenue offers a blend of timeless charm, convenience, and community—making it a top contender for anyone dreaming of suburban life just outside New York City.
A Neighborhood With Character
Each home along Montieth Avenue has its own personality. Some are classic 1930s colonials with front porches and ivy-covered facades, while others are mid-century ranch-style houses with well-manicured lawns and updated interiors. Despite their architectural differences, they share a sense of pride and permanence—this is a street where people stay and put down roots.
Take, for instance, the lovely home at 60 Montieth Avenue—a 1930 build with cozy, classic vibes and original charm that’s been thoughtfully maintained. Just down the street, 100 Montieth Avenue reflects a different era with its low-profile ranch layout and generous backyard. In recent years, homes like these have attracted plenty of attention on the real estate market, thanks to their curb appeal and proximity to Hawthorne’s amenities.
A Desirable Place to Live
Recent real estate activity on Montieth Avenue reveals a strong demand for homes here. The sale of 32 Montieth Avenue in late 2022, a beautifully renovated raised ranch that went for $679,000, is a sign of the area's increasing value and desirability.
Buyers are drawn to more than just the homes—they’re buying into a lifestyle. Hawthorne offers that perfect balance of suburban peace and urban access. Whether you’re commuting into Manhattan via the Hawthorne Metro-North station, or heading to nearby towns like Pleasantville, Valhalla, or White Plains, it’s all within reach.
Everyday Convenience
Montieth Avenue residents enjoy the perks of a well-situated location. You're just minutes from local favorites like Lago Ristorante (for upscale Italian), The Wicked Wolf North (a neighborhood pub), and Lucia’s (a classic diner-style bakery/café). For day-to-day needs, there's a ShopRite, pharmacies, gyms, and specialty stores nearby.
Parks and green spaces are a big part of the appeal. Hillside Park and Roselle Park are within easy driving distance, offering trails, sports fields, and playgrounds for families. The Rockefeller State Park Preserve is just a bit further for those who crave weekend hikes or nature walks.
Schools and Community
Montieth Avenue falls within the highly regarded Mount Pleasant Central School District. Parents appreciate the strong sense of community involvement and the smaller class sizes that come with suburban schools. Hawthorne Elementary, Westlake Middle School, and Westlake High School all have solid reputations and a variety of programs for students.
In addition to good schools, residents enjoy a tight-knit neighborhood atmosphere. Block parties, Halloween parades, and spontaneous driveway conversations are all part of the Montieth experience. There’s a strong sense of belonging—people know each other’s names, and new residents are warmly welcomed.
Montieth Avenue isn’t flashy, and that’s what makes it so special. It’s a slice of classic Westchester—peaceful, picturesque, and practical. Whether you're a young family looking for a place to grow or a downsizer seeking a quieter pace, this neighborhood checks all the boxes.